January 11, 2021

First published January 10, 2021

 in Mid-day

Guru Teaches Autonomy Not Submission

Published on 10th January, 2021, in Mid-day.

The idea of guru being greater than mother, father, even God, is an idea that emerges from medieval times and is articulated in the “Guru Gita”, a conversation between Shiva and Shakti from the Skanda Purana. This chant is very popular today but was not popular in Vedic times, when the guru was essentially acharya (teacher) who was paid fees (dakshina) for his services.

The idea of the charismatic guru, chased by fans and followers, starts with Buddha whose students submitted (sharanam) to him and followed him, until the day he died. This idea recurs in Vajrayana Buddhism and Tantric Buddhism of Nepal and Tibet, where the gurus like 84 Mahasiddhas are admired and worshipped. It is also found in the Nath Yogi traditions where Gorakhnath is completely committed to his master Machindranath. In Islam, everyone is beholden to the Final Messenger, Muhammad Paigamba. In Shia traditions, everyone follows Muhammad’s descendants, the Imam. In folk Islam we find similar adoration of Ghazis and Pir. Here, the chela follows the ustad, very much as the shishya follows the guruji for the rest of his life. He is completely beholden to the guru who has complete power. In Sikhism too, the guru is all supreme and the final guru is a book-the Granth Sahib. Still, the new gurus, who establish deras, have vast number of followers, who do whatever the guru says. There is submission, not autonomy.

However, the Bhagvad Purana talks of the guru of gurus, Dattatreya, who is autonomous. He learns from various plants, animals, elements, human and gods and transmits this knowledge to students. He is no leader who needs followers. Those who follow him are dogs and cows, dogs who need a master, and cows who need protector. Does Dattatreya need the dogs or cows? No, he does not. He has no hunger, so needs no cows. He has no fear, and so needs no dogs. The cows and dogs need him. These are clearly metaphors for those who need an alpha in their life, a protector, a caretaker. But, when autonomous, they rise above their dog-like or cow-like instincts.

Shiva, the guru of the rishis, is Mahadeva, because, unlike the devas, he does not seek to be fed with Soma during a yagna. He is digambara, naked, because he is attached to nothing, neither followers, nor students, nor friends nor family. Ghosts (bhoot-pret) are metaphors for the hungry souls who follow him; they need Shiva, Shiva does not need them. Shiva enables their liberation from the cycle of existence. He does not bind them like gurus today bind students to themselves, entrapping them with love and devotion. Hence, Shiva’s symbol is the ash-the residue of burning all bonds.


Recent Books

  • Itihasa : A History of Hindu Mythology

    Watch this space for more information on the release of Pattanaik’s new book: Itihasa : A History of Hindu Mythology!…

  • flowers of india book

    Flower of India: Ways of Seeing the Lotus

    In Flower of India, bestselling author and renowned mythologist Devdutt Pattanaik examines the lotus as one of the most pervasive and resonant symbols of the Indian subcontinent. Through its many avatars—as plant, resource, metaphor, design, and sacred form—he traces how the lotus has shaped India’s cultural imagination across history, religion, art, and everyday life. Concise…

  • astra shastra

    Astra Shastra: Weapons of the Hindu Gods

    Well-known mythologist Devdutt Pattanaik introduces young readers to the wonderful weapons of Hindu gods with his unique art and easy-to-read text…

  • Escape the Bakasura Trap : Let Contentment Fuel Your Growth

    This book re-discovers this path, first revealed by Hanuman in the Mahabharata. Insightful and inspiring, Escape the Bakasura Trap is another classic from one of our great mythologists and thinkers…

Recent Posts

  • Brahmins In Jain Memory

    Brahmins In Jain Memory

    In the Brahminical tradition, the Brahmin stands at the apex of creation, born from the mouth of Prajapati, custodian of the sacred fire by divine right. Jainism offers a different account entirely. It does not deny the Brahmin’s existence; it explains his origins. It explains his origins. And in doing so, it places him firmly…

  • The Itihasa of Prithviraj Chauhan

    The Itihasa of Prithviraj Chauhan

    Long before the nationalist imagination got to work, two older traditions had already told very different stories about the same king, and neither of them had any use for a hero…

  • Djinns Amongst Us

    Djinns Amongst Us

    The Quran describes jinn as beings created from a “smokeless flame of fire,” while humans were created from clay and angels from light. The Arabic word jinn comes from a root meaning “hidden” or “concealed.” They inhabit a parallel dimension that humans generally cannot perceive. Unlike angels, they possess free will. They can choose faith…