July 27, 2024

First published July 19, 2024

 in Economic Times

Being Cultured In Japan

A tourist in Japan is impressed by Japanese culture -coexistence of modern and traditional, past and future. Yet, it is a xenophobic culture – nice to visitors, not to immigrants. Even though its population is dwindling, it does not allow immigration. Elderly Japanese folk believe that outsiders will not be able to assimilate. They say this even about people who have been living there for generations. Koreans who were forced to settle in Japan around the second world war are still referred to as ‘residents’ still, not citizens.

When we refer to culture, we typically refer to the packaging and the performance – music, costumes, food, dance, literature. We never talk about mindsets. Why are the Japanese who appear so gracious and polite so intolerant of foreign ways? Why is East Asia least concerned by ideas such as ‘diversity and inclusion’?

Around the 17th century, just when Europeans and Christian missionaries were trying to penetrate Asia, the kingdoms of China (Ming), Japan (Edo) and Korea (Joseon) shut their doors to foreigners. They opened up, rather reluctantly, only in the 20th century.

Anyone who has dealt with Japanese people will observe how everything is choreographed and ritualised, even from the act of eating to the act of drinking tea, to arranging flowers, to conducting a meeting, to the act of giving a visiting card with two hands. Such a ritualised society does look rather quaint but it indicates the absence of individual freedom. A rigid ecosystem where everything is controlled. It is all about fitting in the system, being the cog in the wheel. The belief is there is a place for everyone and everyone is a place, but this takes away all diversity and dynamism which is necessary for the growth of a society.

For all its beauty, organisation and modernity, Japan has a high suicide rate. Life is stressful and competitive, with a widespread prevalence of mental health issues, amplified by the refusal to talk about it in public, as complaining brings shame to the family. Sociologists point to the intense violence observed in Japan’s porn industry. The same is true of the anime cartoons which look surreal with their baby-like eyes and the vicious movements of the blood-seeking Samurai sword. Then there are the drunks encountered in Tokyo subways on weekends, the very same people who seem so polished at daytime on weekdays.

Japan was at one time one of the most powerful industrial leaders of the world but currently suffers from negative inflation. This reminds us that technology can be a veneer. Modern clothes and modern tools do not indicate a modern mind, where an individual has agency and the freedom to chart his own course. Japan makes us wonder what is the purpose of culture – to domesticate people, or liberate the human mind.


Recent Books

  • flowers of india book

    Flower of India: Ways of Seeing the Lotus

    In Flower of India, bestselling author and renowned mythologist Devdutt Pattanaik examines the lotus as one of the most pervasive and resonant symbols of the Indian subcontinent. Through its many avatars—as plant, resource, metaphor, design, and sacred form—he traces how the lotus has shaped India’s cultural imagination across history, religion, art, and everyday life. Concise…

  • astra shastra

    Astra Shastra: Weapons of the Hindu Gods

    Well-known mythologist Devdutt Pattanaik introduces young readers to the wonderful weapons of Hindu gods with his unique art and easy-to-read text…

  • Escape the Bakasura Trap : Let Contentment Fuel Your Growth

    This book re-discovers this path, first revealed by Hanuman in the Mahabharata. Insightful and inspiring, Escape the Bakasura Trap is another classic from one of our great mythologists and thinkers…

  • लंकेश: रावण संग एक रोमांचक यात्रा

    यह पुस्तक भारत के सबसे विख्यात महाकाव्य रामायण और इस कारण भारत के सबसे बड़े खलनायक, रावण, को विस्तार से जानने की राह खोलती है।…

Recent Posts

  • The Chandala in the Vedas

    The Chandala in the Vedas

    The term Chandala, referring to the “lowest of the low” in Brahmin lore, appears a few times in the Vedic literature itself. It is essentially absent from the Rigveda Samhita and emerges only in the later strata of the corpus — the later Samhitas, Brahmanas, and Upanishads. …

  • Who Is Baal?

    Who Is Baal?

    The name Baal has been appearing a lot lately, especially in Western media, in the context of war between Iran and Israel. Known as a false god in the Bible, his images are being burnt in public. Western capitalists are being accused of worshipping him secretly as part of a demon cult. Conspiracy theories aside,…

  • The Convenient Politics of “Later Additions” in the Ramayana

    The Convenient Politics of “Later Additions” in the Ramayana

    When Sita is banished to the forest while pregnant, on the basis of nothing more than public gossip, modern readers recoil. Many quickly reach for a comforting explanation: this episode, they say, is a ‘later addition’, an interpolation, not really part of the original Ramayana…