July 12, 2014

First published July 11, 2014

 in The Speaking Tree

May the Most Fertile Win

Published on 11th May, 2014, in The Speaking Tree.

One day, during a yoga class, one of the students was counting the number of times he was doing a particular asana. The teacher stopped the student saying, “This is not a competition. This is yoga. Don’t count. Just focus on the experience of doing it.”

This attitude is sadly missing in our democracy, which is based on counting, and is all about notching up votes, capturing more and more seats in the assembly. It is competitive, full of fierce rivalries. It is based on the assumption that one with most votes is most popular hence most worthy of managing the country. Popularity has become the measure of capability. This makes democracy much like ancient fertility rituals where more was good.

In the Vedic mantras we find that the yajaman prays to the devas and hopes to get more cows, more horses, more grain, more gold and more sons, because having more made him richer and more powerful than everyone else around him. Vedanta philosophy, however, questions this logic. Stories are told to make us aware that what matters more than quantity is quality. Its not how many asanas we do; the benefit of yoga comes from how we do each one.

In the Mahabharata, keeping score is the cause of many battles. It starts generations before, at the dawn of time, when Kashyapa is given the task of populating the world with various creatures through his many wives. His wife, Kadru, says, “I want many children.” Another wife, Vinata, says, “I want just two, but who will be stronger than all of Kadru’s children put together.” Kadru’s children turn out to be snakes or nagas while Vinata’s child (the first one is delivered prematurely and so is malformed) turns out to be a hawk or garuda. The snakes are more numerous but the hawk is much more strong. This results in a lifetime of rivalry between the insecure snakes and the powerful eagle.

This pattern repeats itself later in the epic. Shatanu’s first wife, the river-goddess Ganga, gives him just one son while his second wife, the fisherwoman Satyavati, bears two. The only son of the first wife, Devavrata, is strong but is asked to stay celibate and give up claims on the throne so that the sons of the second wife can inherit the throne. But both sons of Satyavati prove to be useless. The first is killed by a gandharva and the second dies childless despite being given two wives. Thus numerical superiority does not grant the desired results and ends up creating a mess.

Much later, Pandu is unable to father children and so begs his wife, Kunti, to take advantage of her mantra and call upon devas who will give her a child. She calls upon Yama, Vayu and Indra and begets Yudhishtira, Bhima and Arjuna. Pandu asks for more sons, but Kunti says she cannot it use it more than three times. So Pandu begs her to share the mantra with his second wife, Madri. Kunti does as advised but is quite irritated when using one mantra Madri begets two children by simply calling the Ashwin Kumars who always come in a pair. She refuses to give Madri the mantra again as she wants to be the mother of more children. This little detail from the Sanskrit work is often avoided in popular retellings of the Mahabharata as we find the idea of a competitive Kunti unappealing. This tale also reveals the competitive anxiety of Pandu when he seeks more and more sons, for he wants to have more sons than his very virile brother, Dhritarashtra. Unfortunately, Dhritarashtra’s wife, Gandhari, is so upset that Kunti bears children before her that she makes her midwife strike her pregnant belly with an iron bar and force the child out. What she delivers instead is a ball of flesh, cold as iron. This she divides and transforms, with the aid of Rishi Vyasa, to get hundred sons, 98 more than Madri, 97 more than Kunti, 100 more than Pandu, to establish her and her husband’s superiority.

The counting continues as the sons of Pandu, the Pandavas, and the sons of Dhritarashtra, the Kauravas, continuously compete. Arjuna keeps securing wives for himself such as Uloopi, Chitrangada and Subhadra and in Tamil folk Mahabharata he has ‘more wives than stars in the sky’ including the Amazon princess Alli. We wonder if this stems from his competitive spirit being challenged when he is asked to share Draupadi, the bride he won, with his brothers.

And finally, in the Kurukshetra war, using various political tricks, the Kauravas end up with 11 armies, 4 more than the 7 armies of the Pandavas. They have more, and still they lose, for they reject Krishna.


Recent Books

  • flowers of india book

    Flower of India: Ways of Seeing the Lotus

    In Flower of India, bestselling author and renowned mythologist Devdutt Pattanaik examines the lotus as one of the most pervasive and resonant symbols of the Indian subcontinent. Through its many avatars—as plant, resource, metaphor, design, and sacred form—he traces how the lotus has shaped India’s cultural imagination across history, religion, art, and everyday life. Concise…

  • astra shastra

    Astra Shastra: Weapons of the Hindu Gods

    Well-known mythologist Devdutt Pattanaik introduces young readers to the wonderful weapons of Hindu gods with his unique art and easy-to-read text…

  • Escape the Bakasura Trap : Let Contentment Fuel Your Growth

    This book re-discovers this path, first revealed by Hanuman in the Mahabharata. Insightful and inspiring, Escape the Bakasura Trap is another classic from one of our great mythologists and thinkers…

  • लंकेश: रावण संग एक रोमांचक यात्रा

    यह पुस्तक भारत के सबसे विख्यात महाकाव्य रामायण और इस कारण भारत के सबसे बड़े खलनायक, रावण, को विस्तार से जानने की राह खोलती है।…

Recent Posts

  • Of Jains And Jews

    Of Jains And Jews

    The comparison between Jains in India and Jews in Europe reveals two remarkably similar minority communities with profoundly different historical destinies. Both occupied economically influential positions disproportionate to their demographic size. Both cultivated strong internal discipline, dietary codes, educational traditions and merchant ethics. Yet while Europe repeatedly produced violent anti-Semitism culminating in genocide, India never…

  • India Between Empires: A Reality Check

    India Between Empires: A Reality Check

    India has always been sandwiched between East Asia and West Asia. From the West, came horses. From the East came gold. India itself was the land of cotton – it had neither metal nor horses…

  • Tantra of the Wheel of Time

    Tantra of the Wheel of Time

    Compiled in the early eleventh century as Muslim armies pressed into northwest India, the Kalacakratantra — the Wheel of Time Tantra — is one of the clearest cases in religious history of a sacred text designed as a political response to a contemporary threat. …